Overnight Charter in the Hamptons
An overnight charter in the Hamptons is the one trip where the details decide whether you enjoy it. Where you spend the night, which way the wind is blowing, and what the boat actually has aboard matter more than the itinerary. Not every vessel is set up for it, so this trip runs on select boats only and availability is limited. We're Charters in The Hamptons, a family-run operation on Shelter Island. Call (631) 251-1777 and we'll tell you what's available for your dates.
Start With the Boat
This is the first conversation, not the last one. Overnight comfort depends entirely on the vessel: how many can sleep aboard, what the head and shower situation is, and whether there's shade and shelter for the evening.
We won't publish those specifics here, because they differ by boat and the wrong answer ruins a trip. Call and tell us your group size and dates, and we'll tell you exactly which vessels are set up for overnights and what each one has.
Where You'd Actually Spend the Night
The East End has some of the best protected overnight water in the Northeast, and choosing well is most of the job.
​
-
Coecles Harbor, on the east side of Shelter Island, is protected in nearly any wind and has a designated anchoring area. It's the default recommendation for a reason.
-
Smith Cove, on the south side just past the South Ferry, is quiet and pretty with an open western view.
-
Dering Harbor, on the north side by the Greenport ferry, is deep and protected and puts you close to the village.
-
West Neck Harbor is beautiful and shallow, with a narrow entrance you don't take casually.
-
Greenport has transient dockage at Mitchell Park Marina and other spots if you'd rather tie up in town than swing on the hook.
Your captain picks based on the forecast. A cove that's perfect in a northerly is uncomfortable in a southwest breeze, which is the prevailing summer wind here.
Slips and Moorings Aren't Reserved
Transient dockage and moorings across the East End are generally first come, first served. That's true at most restaurant docks and at many marinas. Plan to arrive earlier than feels necessary, especially on summer weekends.
The No Discharge Rule
Worth knowing before you spend a night aboard. The entire Peconic Estuary has been a federally recognized vessel waste No Discharge Zone since 2002, covering all waters west of a line from Orient Point to Montauk Point.
​
Nothing goes overboard. Holding tanks get emptied at a pumpout facility ashore or by a pumpout boat you can hail on the radio. It's the reason the shellfish beds and swimming water out here are as clean as they are, and every boat follows it. More detail is available from the Peconic Estuary Partnership.
What an Overnight Feels Like
Different from a day trip in a way people don't anticipate.
The bay empties out around six. Day boats head in, the wind usually drops, and the water goes flat. That last hour of light at anchor is the best part of the whole trip, and it's the part nobody who leaves at five ever sees.
Then it gets genuinely dark out here. There's very little light pollution over the Peconics, and on a clear night at anchor the sky is worth staying up for.
Mornings are the other reward. Flat water, no traffic, and birds working the shallows before anyone else is awake.
What to Bring
-
Layers, and more than you'd pack for a day. It gets cold on the water at night even in July.
-
A soft bag rather than a hard suitcase. Boats don't have closets.
-
Food and drinks for the whole stay, plus more water than you think.
-
Sunscreen, hats, and something warm for the evening.
-
Any medication you need, since you won't be near a pharmacy.
Talk to us about a bad-weather plan when you book. Overnight trips are more weather-dependent than day trips and your captain will make the call.
Where You Could Go
Most overnights stay inside the protected Peconics, which is the comfortable choice. Longer runs to Block Island or Fishers Island are a different proposition and need more planning, more weather flexibility, and an honest conversation about the crossing.
Tell us what you have in mind on the first call and we'll be straight about what's realistic.
Best Months for an Overnight
June and September are the two we'd point you toward.
June gives you the longest evenings of the year. The sun doesn't set until about 8:25 p.m. around the solstice, which makes for a very long, very good stretch of light at anchor.
September is warmer than people expect, the water is at its warmest of the whole year, and the anchorages empty out after Labor Day. Sunset comes earlier, around 6:32 p.m. by month's end, so the evening starts sooner and the night sky arrives while you're still awake to enjoy it.
July and August work too, but the popular anchorages are busier and the good boats book out furthest ahead.
Why Book With Us
We're cousins who grew up in the marina business on Shelter Island, working the docks before we earned USCG licenses in 2019. More than 200 charters since.
​
-
We know which anchorage is comfortable in which wind, which is the entire game overnight.
-
Every captain holds a USCG license.
-
Private charters only.
-
Central base with the best protected water in the region right outside.
Ask About Availability
Overnight boats are limited and summer dates go early. The sooner you call, the better your options.
Call or text (631) 251-1777, or email captain@chartersinthehamptons.com. We're at 63 S Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964.
See our boats or contact us.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which boats can do overnights? Only select vessels are set up for it. Call (631) 251-1777 with your dates and group size and we'll tell you which ones are available.
How many people can stay aboard? It depends entirely on the boat, and it's a different number from how many the vessel carries for a day trip. Give us the head count first.
Where do we spend the night? Usually a protected anchorage like Coecles Harbor or Smith Cove, or a transient slip in Greenport. Your captain picks based on the forecast.
Can we book a slip in advance? Most East End transient dockage is first come, first served. That's why we plan arrival times carefully rather than counting on a reserved space.
What happens with the head overnight? The Peconic Estuary is a No Discharge Zone, so holding tanks are emptied at a pumpout ashore or by pumpout boat. Nothing goes overboard.
What if the weather turns? Your captain makes the call, and overnights get postponed more readily than day trips. Talk through rescheduling when you book.
Is an overnight suitable for kids? It can be, on the right boat and in a protected anchorage. Tell us the ages when you call and we'll be honest about whether it will work for your group.
Can we go to Block Island overnight? It's possible but it's a real crossing and it needs planning and weather flexibility. Call and we'll tell you honestly whether your dates work.
